A new storm is brewing in India’s digital landscape, and at its center is Elon Musk’s AI chatbot, Grok. Launched in February 2025 as a free service on X (formerly Twitter), Grok has quickly become the subject of heated debate, drawing sharp reactions for its unfiltered, often provocative responses. From using Hindi slang to making controversial remarks about Indian political leaders, Grok has set off alarm bells among government officials and tech policy experts alike.
Grok’s ‘Unhinged’ Responses Spark Outrage
It all started when Indian users on X began testing Grok’s limits by asking politically sensitive and controversial questions. The chatbot did not hold back. Its responses included slang, explicit language, and even derogatory remarks. Queries about Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi led to eyebrow-raising answers that quickly went viral.
Screenshots of Grok’s responses flooded social media, with users questioning how long it would take before the chatbot faced a ban in India. The situation escalated further when the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) stepped in, announcing an investigation into Grok’s responses and their compliance with India’s IT regulations.
Government Scrutiny and Potential Crackdown
The IT Ministry wasted no time in engaging with X executives to understand why Grok was generating such content. According to ministry officials, discussions are ongoing to determine if the chatbot’s responses violate India’s strict digital content laws.
“We are actively communicating with X to address the concerns surrounding Grok. The focus is on ensuring AI-generated content remains within legal boundaries while respecting free speech,” an anonymous IT Ministry official told PTI.
If the government deems Grok’s behavior unacceptable, it could lead to strict regulatory action, including possible restrictions or outright bans. This wouldn’t be the first time India has taken a strong stance on digital content—previous crackdowns on social media platforms have shown the government’s zero-tolerance policy towards content deemed harmful or inflammatory.
Experts Weigh In: Free Speech or Unchecked AI?
While the government deliberates, technology and legal experts are raising critical questions about the future of AI in public discourse. Pranesh Prakash, co-founder of the Centre for Internet and Society, cautioned against hasty regulations that could stifle innovation and create a precedent for censorship.
“The IT Ministry is not responsible for ensuring that all AI-generated content adheres to parliamentary language. The real concern is whether regulatory pressure will push companies into excessive self-censorship, thereby chilling free speech,” Prakash explained.
The debate touches on deeper issues of accountability—should X be held responsible for what Grok says? Under Section 79 of the IT Act, platforms generally enjoy immunity from third-party content. However, this protection comes with obligations, including acting against content that violates laws.
Musk’s Reaction: A Laughing Matter?
Elon Musk, never one to shy away from controversy, responded to the uproar with a laughing emoji on X. His lighthearted reaction suggests he sees the backlash as overblown, in line with his vision of Grok as an “anti-woke” AI alternative.
Musk has previously criticized AI models like ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini for what he perceives as left-leaning biases. In an interview last year, he said, “I’m worried that AI is being trained to be politically correct rather than truthful.” His goal with Grok was to create a chatbot that gives “spicy” and unfiltered responses. But where does one draw the line between unfiltered truth and offensive rhetoric?
Grok’s Unfiltered Approach: A Feature or a Flaw?
Unlike other AI chatbots, Grok is integrated directly with X, meaning users can simply tag it in their posts to receive a response. This seamless integration also means that unfiltered content can spread rapidly across the platform.
Tech policy analyst Rohit Kumar believes this is where the real danger lies. “The issue isn’t just what Grok says, but how easily its responses can be amplified across a massive social media network. If users perceive its answers as factual, the potential for misinformation is enormous,” Kumar warned.
Grok’s ability to pull real-time data from X also adds to the concern. While other AI models rely on pre-trained datasets, Grok can analyze and respond to live trends. But without clear oversight, this capability could lead to the rapid spread of misinformation.
India’s History with AI and Free Speech Regulation
This is not the first time India has grappled with the regulation of AI-generated content. Just last year, the government introduced, then withdrew, an AI advisory that sought to impose stricter content moderation rules on AI-generated media. The pushback from tech firms and free speech advocates led to its retraction, but the underlying concerns remain.
India’s laws already place restrictions on speech that can incite violence or disrupt public order. The question now is whether these laws should extend to AI. Can an AI chatbot be held accountable for its statements? Should AI-generated speech be treated the same as human speech in legal frameworks?
Meghna Bal, director at the Esya Centre, argues that context matters. “Whether AI-generated content qualifies as free speech depends on whether it crosses legal boundaries. The law does not distinguish between AI and human speech when it comes to prohibited content.”
What’s Next for Grok in India?
For now, Grok remains active in India, but its future hangs in the balance. If the government decides to take action, X may have to modify Grok’s responses or implement stricter content moderation measures.
As AI continues to blur the lines between free expression and digital chaos, the Grok controversy serves as a wake-up call. How nations choose to regulate AI today could shape the future of online discourse for years to come.
The final verdict on Grok? Still pending. But one thing is certain—this debate is far from over.
Login with Google